Overvaluing Automatons: Workaholism or Hard Work?

Tuesday, October 9, 2012



"I did not want [my child] to end up like one of those weird Asian automatons who feel so much pressure . . . that they kill themselves after coming in second on the national civil service exam."
- Amy Chua, Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother

Hard work and workaholism are not the same thing. Hard work is a character strength. Workaholism implies poor priorities and an imbalanced life. And yet, Americans increasingly have to be more like workaholics than hard workers to attain the highest levels of success in this country. Although many businesses, hospitals, and professional firms promote work-life balance to attract and keep high quality employees, many still have corporate cultures that value very long hours and promote employees based almost entirely on productivity ($$ per person) without regard for other circumstances. Firms say and do two different things. They advertise that they value employees and then treat them as liabilities rather than assets. In fact, many of the most prestigious career fields in America require at least a few years of totally unbalanced devotion to work. To become a top lawyer, you have to put in backbreaking billable hours as a junior associate. Then, of those workaholics, only one in five makes partner: the one who puts in the most hours. To become a physician, you have to do a few years as a resident putting in 75-hour workweeks with a frenetic schedule and then you're on call (in 2003, OSHA adopted an 80-hour limitation with exceptions, how generous of them). To become a business executive, the standard path involves doing your time at a major consulting, accounting, or investment banking firm.  But, are these long hours really good for us? Or are these long-hour rites of passage really just chest pounding, bragging rights, proof of manhood? Workaholism is fostered early on too. Test scores at universities are based solely on productivity and are the greatest determinant of career opportunity. In the end, this is understandable right? Businesses are profit-maximizers and getting more work out of fewer people seems like it would cut costs and increase net income.

But, even if overworking employees does make for higher profits, isn't it the government's job to correct for the excesses of business' constant quest for profit? Shouldn't we have a system where those living a balanced lifestyle are rewarded? America lags far behind developed countries with regards to family-oriented workplace policies like maternity leave, support for working mothers, maximum working hours, and vacation time. On average, Americans work 30% more hours than Europeans, yet American and European workers are virtually equal in their productivity. Studies show that working more than 50 hours a week might increase productivity for some people, but only very marginally. In other words, if you are a workaholic, you might get the most done, but insignificantly in the big picture. The hours aren't worth the increase in productivity. Studies show that, on average, productivity after 50 hour of work in a week drops off precipitously. For example, Albert studies for 50 hours in a week and scores a 90% on his law school exam. Bertrand studies for 80 hours a week and scores a 95% on that same exam. Since most law schools have a mandatory curve, Albert gets a B+ and Bertrand gets an A. Now, in law school terms, the difference between a 3.3 (B+) GPA and a 3.7 (A-) GPA can be as much as $100,000 difference in salary. But, is that how it should work? Should we really value Bertrand's marginal increase in legal knowledge (that can be found with a click of a button) at $100k? While Bertrand was outlining campaign finance law in the library for 30 extra hours, Albert took his son fishing, his daughter to swimming lessons, went on a date with his wife, volunteered for the Special Olympics, went to the gym three times, read a book, took a nap, and helped a friend change his brake pads.  Who is really more productive? Who is more honorable? Who would you want as your leader?

The overworking of Americans has a number of negative effects on individuals and on society as a whole. 

Materialism: First, emphasis on long work hours puts a premium on money and devalues time (time with family, time with friends, time doing service, time on hobbies, etc). Hours worked per person in America has steadily increased since the late 1940s while salaries per hour worked have doubled since then when adjusted for inflation. In other words, Americans could work 4-hour days and have the same quality of life as they would have earned for themselves in an 8-hour work day in 1940. Commercialism has convinced too many Americans that stuff is more valuable than it really is.

Sleep: If you need an alarm clock, you are probably not getting enough sleep. Every year, the sleep deficit among American workers grows. Most Americans are getting over an hour less sleep than they should.

Experience: There is an argument that we are getting boring as we take less and less vacation and fewer and fewer hobbies. We aren't traveling as much for pleasure or learning. Jobs are requiring us to become increasingly specialized and job satisfaction declines with the diminished variety. We can't pursue hobbies or side-jobs anymore. There's not time to produce that great idea for an invention, write that book, or teach yourself to knit. We work, eat, sleep and repeat. We don't have time to meditate and think about life or to engage in meaningful conversation.

Health: Stress in American workers is measurably higher with each passing year. This contributes to a host of mental and physical health problems that are on the rise. The stress also has a negative effect on our relationships with others. We are less happy and more depressed than ever. In addition, long work schedules often make for more sedentary lifestyles that contribute to problems like, among others, obesity and cardiovascular complications.

Unemployment: Increasing hours for employees means less people get hired.

Family: This is the most unfortunate casualty of our overvaluation of long hours at work. I don't even know where to begin. Marriages are strained as husband and wife spend less time with one another and don't have time to complete household chores. Parents spend less time with kids. Kids are left home alone more and more. Even when a person has time for their spouse or children, fatigue usually makes that time less effective for bonding. Couples are putting off getting married or having kids until after school or after my first job or after whatever so that they can be more successful in their careers. I think this lack of love and spending time together leads to lower morals too. When we don't feel cared for, we generally hold ourselves to lower standards of conduct. Friends can be a strength, but family is where moral support most happens. Mothers should be able to put their families first and still become physicians, but the system does not allow it nor does the impossible ideal of "supermom" help the situation. It ignores the problem.

One way to deal with this problem would be to set a maximum work hour ceiling. Perhaps employers would be prohibited by statute to work their employees for more than an average of 60 hours a week over a ten week period. That isn't setting the ceiling too low. Or, perhaps tax incentives could be set up to encourage employers to work employees at reasonable hours and to make it not worth overworking employees. Perhaps a minimum vacation requirement of 14-days a year should be instituted. I would also like to see policy incentives for improved maternity leave and accommodations for mothers at work (e.g. breastfeeding breaks, mothers' rooms). 

As an aside, I prefer that protecting employee work-life balance is better accomplished by statutes than by empowering labor unions. Labor unions have a natural tendency to carry their fight for workers to excess just as unchecked businesses seem to go too far the other way. Can everyone agree that working more than 60-hour weeks with only one week of vacation time, and zero sick pay is inconsistent with a balanced life? In my opinion, the law could appropriately set some minimum standards through taxation or outright prohibitions.

Finally, I'd like to see education policy shift to better esteem students with balanced lives and talents that fit particular career fields rather than abstract academics only. Work-life balance is not so much a problem in public high schools where the homework load is relatively quite low; but in graduate professional schools it is certainly a problem. Slightest differences in capacity are blown out of proportion in assessments and in school's representations to employers of a student's worth. Perhaps simply measuring competency in individual subject areas and forcing employers to sift through potential employees would be a better system for many professional graduate schools. The current system seems to enable elitism too much as well. I'd also like to see alternatives to medical residencies or grueling junior associate rites of passage. Perhaps a 5-year residency at 40 hours a week rather than a 3-year residency at 75 hours per week. Maybe a 12-year partnership track rather than a 7-year track.

We don't want to become automatons that feel they have to sacrifice faith, family, friends, or service to become a law firm partner or a physician. For stronger families, happier citizens, and (yes) a stronger economy, we need to reward those who live balanced lives. 

Equality of Opportunity and Equality of Outcome

Tuesday, October 2, 2012



There are two notions of equality that drive different political ideologies. The first is equality of opportunity. An equality of opportunity approach seeks to level the playing field by making the law apply equally to everyone. The second kind of equality is equality of outcomes. Equality of outcomes seeks to ensure that everyone ends up in the same conditions. The two are mutually exclusive to some degree as equality of opportunity implies certain inequality of outcome. Only equality of opportunity is consistent with pure liberty. But, what kind of “equality of opportunity” should we seek in America? And, is the line between the two as clear as one might like to think?

Let’s look at a case study of affirmative action. The issue is obviously complex and some oversimplification will unfortunately be necessary to fit this into a neat little blog post. Racial inequality is measurable by educational indicators, socio-economic circumstances, crime rates, single mothers, and by a number of other sociological gauges. To correct for these inequalities, various affirmative action policies have been put into effect. Affirmative action policies can perhaps be grouped into two primary types. First, there are systematic remedies that seek to level the playing field and make the rules apply to everyone the same. Secondly, there are redistributive policies that seek to open up new opportunities.

What would justify affirmative action? Presumably, most all affirmative action policies would be unjustifiable if racial inequality arises from (1) innate biological inferiority (overwhelming evidence refutes this notion entirely); (2) cultural pathologies that deemphasize hard work, education, etc (some empirical evidence supports this); or (3) voluntary choices to pursue the paths that they do (very unlikely). However, what affirmative action policies are justified if (a) discrimination and stereotypes play a role in keeping a race down (informal barriers) or (b) structural based obstacles like segregation or a lack of family connections work against a race (formal barriers)?

Even libertarians think that structural or systematic obstacles stemming from government’s duplicitous treatment of different races should be abolished. But, to the extent that discrimination (overt and unconscious) still exists, should quotas, recruiting campaigns, or employee support programs be provided to members of a disadvantaged race? Although express quotas in hiring and school admissions are prohibited by law, unspoken redistributions of opportunity in many careers and school admissions are measurable statistically and legal. So, should discrimination be remedied by redistributions of opportunities? Such an approach would be an equality of outcomes approach. 

Affirming a belief in equality of opportunity implies a belief that government should make sure everyone starts off in the same place, not that everyone ends up in the same condition. However, the issue is complicated by the fact that people aren’t born in the same place. Although we are all of equal value in the eyes of our Heavenly Father, some of us are born to poor parents, others to rich parents; some are born in the United States, others in Somalia; some to parents who love one another, others never know one of their parents; etc. The only way to get everyone started off equally would be to institute some Spartan program of community child-rearing and a total prohibition of any gifts whether given inter vivos or after death. However, that just seems inherently wrong and completely inconsistent with freedom.

Should we simply ignore birth inequalities? I am tempted to say that it is better to let mysterious fate distribute opportunity rather than the arbitrary or fleeting preferences of government. But, I don’t think such an extreme view is the only answer to this puzzle.

A certain degree of economic inequality is desirable. Inequality provides rewards for hard work, talent, and achievement. It provides lubricant for social enterprise and progress. However, when inequality becomes too great, it animates pride, exploitation, discontent, and rebellion that cause societal decline. When crafting solutions to inequality, government should not focus on where to strike a balance between inequality and equality. Rather, I think the focus should be on balancing economic mobility with the freedom to bequest good things to our loved ones. That isn’t very precise; but I don’t think precise is possible. The slightest possibility of reaching the top of the Forbes Richest People list in a single lifetime is all that is necessary for proper income mobility in my view. 

I am thus only in favor of redistributive policies to the extent that all people have the minimum necessities of education, food, shelter, medical care, and life guidance to change their own fortunes and achieve unlimited success with the probabilities of economic success (for full-time, committed individuals mid-career) being chartable on a bell curve. With a more virtuous society, the bell curve will shift towards the prosperous; with a society in moral decline will shift towards the poor. But, the possibility to succeed or to lose should always be present. Real freedom can only be present if we are responsible for the consequences of our choices.

Given my acceptance of some forms of redistributive policies, it is worth mentioning that such policies have been egregiously mismanaged. First, the government not only redistributes things that are not the minimum necessities I described, but are actually detrimental to a disadvantaged person's chances of improving his or her situation. People don’t need a T.V. In fact, TVs do more damage than good. Somehow, people on government stipends for poverty, unemployment, etc afford televisions. People don’t need more bedrooms than there are people in their family; yet I see that in my service to those in government subsidized (or furnished) housing.  And, even the things government provides that people do need as minimum necessities are mismanaged on a large scale. Student loans are given in excessive amounts and without any risk assessment. Medicare pays for unnecessary stuff and pays more for the same services when compared to Veteran Affairs. Redundant programs (there are 23 agencies that provide independent and overlapping assistance to former USSR countries, 12 agencies that ensure food safety requirements are met, and the list goes on for a very long time) are the norm. The mismanagement of what should be proper government redistribution and regulation purposes cannot be understated.

I should also say that income mobility is not the most important thing in the world. Even people who end up not able to break through their birth social class can live joyful and meaningful lives. Indeed, the rich are often less happy, probably because they focus too much on money and too little on the more important things of life like faith, family, friends, and developing an honorable and virtuous character. Equality and freedom are instrumental in bringing forth a virtuous society. But, neither is the end in itself. Government policies should reflect that emphasis on virtuous living through freedom and equality rather than freedom and equality at the expense of virtue.





Free Speech and the Middle East

Tuesday, September 25, 2012



The United States Ambassador to Libya, J. Christopher Stevens, was killed by an armed Islamist mob attack on September 11, 2012. Originally, the Obama administration stated that the attacks were a “spontaneous reaction” to “a hateful and offensive video…” (Susan Rice, U.S. Ambassador to the UN). The video she was referring to was an amateur film, made in the U.S., which mocked Islam and was called “Innocence of Muslims.” This initial reaction was probably false as the timing (11 years to the day after September 11, 2001 attacks) and subsequent investigations appear to show the attack was coordinated and planned. Whatever the case may be, there have been many violent anti-American and anti-West demonstrations and actions throughout the Muslim world ostensibly as a reaction to the wildly unprofessional “Innocence of Muslims” movie trailer or the French publication, Charlie Hebdo, who published cartoons mocking the prophet Mohamed.

These events highlight a major difference in the way some Muslims (enough to fill big town squares during the workweek) and the West view free speech and tolerance of religion. In this post, I attempt to color that difference, to comment on American free speech, and to talk about my own view of free speech.

AMERICAN FREE EXPRESSION

The First Amendment states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” This view of free expression and religion is inherited, in large part, from John Lock and John Stuart Mills. Locke believed that keeping established religion within the heart and home and out of political policymaking would lead to tolerance and end wars of religion. John Stuart Mills advocated the value of a marketplace of ideas. In essence, he thought that, although imperfect, the free trade in ideas was the best way to find truth as a society. Other philosophical justifications undergird American freedom of expression too. Self-governance requires freedom of opinion, religion, and expression. Suffrage requires it. If people are to be sovereign, they must have their own free opinions and be able to express them. There is also a deontological argument that it is an essential right for autonomous and self-determining human beings to express themselves. Otherwise, life would be meager. Free speech serves as a check to the abuse of power.  Free expression serves as a release or safety valve giving a recourse to dissidents other than draconian violence.

MUSLIM FREE EXPRESSION

Many Muslims do believe in free expression. Modernity, it appears, demands it, and it really seems easily reconcilable with the teachings of the Koran as I understand. Yet, too many Muslims refuse to embrace tolerance and free expression. Too few are willing to be offended in order to have peace and free conversation. For them, there is no difference between public and private. The reputation and integrity of their religion outweighs free speech and tolerance. If America disagreed with the distasteful speech, they believe, the government would prohibit it. Since America doesn't censor the speech, they must condone it. For such extremists, an offense to the religion is a personal assault not to be met with more words only, but also violence. If the Americans wont stop the speech that attacks them, they feel entitled to do it themselves.

Some of the Muslim world is easily offended. The reason for this is deep and tender. The beginning of Muslim history is one of spectacular success. The religion started in the 7th Century in the desolate and poor Arabian Peninsula and within a few hundred years spread from Spain to Indonesia. Muslim science and trade surpassed that of the entire world. The thinking of their philosophers was cutting-edge for the day. They had amazing architecture, art, and literature. Islam was great and was supposed to spread throughout all the world.

But, it didn’t. The fall of the Muslim, and particularly Arab Muslims, was swift and brutal. Mongols, Europeans, and Turks beat them militarily and surpassed their knowledge in humanities and sciences, and prospered above them. Even the most proud of Arab Muslims, when you talk to them, seem to be tenderly aware of their culture’s weaknesses and failures. The poverty, disparate treatment between men and women, rich and poor, and from faction to faction are all too easily observable to ignore. When outsiders poke at those tender weaknesses, some Arab Muslims explode into anger and violence.

In a way, their feelings are understandable; yet, violence is only hurting their culture more and incurring more disrespect and ridicule from outsiders. Taking responsibility as a society and channeling that frustration into improving life in the Arab world is the proper direction; not violence against annoying speech. Turkey, currently ruled by an Islamist party, has embraced pluralism and is one of the most respected and prosperous Muslim countries in the world. In some ways, Turkey is an example of a better direction. I am optimistic that change will come, perhaps slowly, but it will.

RECONCILING RIGHTS OF SPEECH WITH OTHER RIGHTS AND THE INTERESTS OF THE STATE

The right to free expression is not without bounds. It is necessarily delimited by other individual rights held by American citizens. In my view, the primary interests of the State are protecting its citizen’s individual rights and promoting a virtuous society. Freedom of speech and the right to receive information freely should be unfettered to the extent that it does not impinge on the rights of others. However, when the rights of others are affected (e.g. perhaps yelling fire in a crowded theatre or verbally abusing someone day in and day out week after week) then the state has the legitimate right to restrict the expression and receiving of information.

When a question arises as to where to draw the line between the right to free speech and some corresponding and mutually exclusive right, courts and legislatures should engage in an analysis similar to equal protection under the 14th Amendment. Laws restrictive of speech based on viewpoint are particularly suspect, content-based restrictions are suspect on an intermediate level, and content-neutral restrictions are presumed to be a legitimate use of State power unless proven otherwise. I assert that citizens should be afforded the RIGHT to pursue moral living without burdens that a reasonable or average American could not withstand. In other words, if they are accosted by pornography or abusive language or intellectual dishonesty that would overcome an average person’s ability to reason or live honorably within broad strokes of morality, than the law should be quick to limit speech at that point. Insults, blather, pornography, obscenity, threats, objective falsehoods, and the like are of such slight value as a step to truth, that the benefits of free speech are plainly outweighed by the broad morality, safety, and order such speech threaten. As we become a more virtuous society, the abilities of a reasonable person might improve. However, I believe that moderating free expression, not to promote morality, but to enable morality, is within the providence of government. Freedom is necessary for a virtuous society.

The Future Role of Finance in the United States

Monday, September 3, 2012

                                                                                          Photo: Ramy Majouji

In this post, I will try to paint in broad strokes my understanding of what caused the 2007 economic downturn and what I think it should mean for the future of the finance sector in the United States.

Starting in the 1990s and continuing into 2006, housing prices increased steadily and substantially. Variable rate mortgages and other sub-prime loans were riskily extended to those with relatively low credit ratings. Buyers assumed they would be able to pay the higher interest rates that kicked in after a designated time period because they thought their careers would progress or, in the alternative, they thought they could just sell their house for a profit. Overconfidence in the stability of the rising housing market prompted speculators to purchase, flip, and develop real property with little hesitation. The housing bubble grew until it burst in late-2006 and 2007. In most of the country, home prices initially only stalled. However, in markets like Florida, Nevada, Arizona, and California where there was an especially pronounced oversupply of housing, the prices dropped abruptly. The other states followed suit.

Then, in 2008, Bear Stearns, a giant investment bank was pulled into the red by its failing hedge funds that were heavily composed of investments in mortgage backed securities. Government sponsored enterprises Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, dealers in mortgage backed securities, were both collapsing. The U.S. government took over management of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and bailed out AIG, a reinsurer of mortgage securities that was on the brink of failure too. By March of 2009, the Dow Jones had dropped from a high of 14,000 in 2006 to a mere 6,547.

Other financial industry giants were also failing. Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy and Merrill Lynch sold out to Bank of America hastily to avoid the same red-lettered fate. With other banking institutions like Citigroup teetering, the Legislature passed a $700 billion (yes, billion; as much as the entire GDP of Indonesia) bailout called TARP. They bought billions of dollars worth of stock in banks like Citigroup and guaranteed billions more dollars in loans. Taxpayers might still be Citigroup's largest shareholder. And yet, they cannot pass the government stress test even today.

The manufacturing industry suffered as a result of the crisis too. So the government poured billions of additional dollars into General Motors and Chrysler in addition to the TARP bailout. But both automobile companies and numerous other manufacturing companies went bankrupt anyway.

These problems affected the entire economy, making for fewer American jobs. In an effort to raise the unemployment rate, Congress provided a $787.2 billion (although the encumbered nature of some of the "investments" probably raise the true price to above $1 trillion) Economic Stimulus Package. Near the same time, Congress guaranteed billions more dollars of loans to failed banks.

The economic downturn has engendered a lot of anger (often directed at the finance industry and politicians) and even more finger pointing. Most likely, the combination of low mortgage interest rates and deregulation was the primary cause, although financial globalization, global imbalance of debt surplus and deficit, executive compensation, and credit cards among other factors likely contributed to the problem. The blame game is futile. What is important is learning from the past and moving forward instead of backwards (although perhaps something we did in the past is better).

We should not be mad at finance as a whole. The finance sector and many of its innovative financial instruments have enabled socially beneficial enterprises that were unimaginable before stock markets, mortgages, loans, bonds, swaps, options, micro-loans, crowd funding, etc. Therefore, the solution to the economic downturn caused by the housing crash is not to hastily restrict the size and inventiveness of the finance and business industries. Rather, regulations should be thought-out and designed to channel financial creativity in ways that most benefits the ability of small businesses and huge corporations to capitalize, grow, innovate, and succeed on the world stage.

One challenge faced by legislatures and economic policymakers is the fact that innovations in finance often help society; but, innovations in finance make finance more complex and harder to predict and understand thus making them more risky. Perhaps the price for the benefits of big and complex finance instruments is occasional bubbles and economic downturns. But, perhaps the cost is worth it. On the other hand, repentance is often harder than not messing up in the first place. Perhaps getting out of the economic ditches does take longer than not getting in them in the first place. I don't know the answer. But, I bet it is somewhere in the middle. Nations that are slow to innovate in finance and who make it hard to buy and sell risk lag behind other nations in political stability and economic growth (e.g. compare Ghana and S. Korea who had similar political and economic situations in 1960. Other factors played a role too [fertility rates, Ghana taking IMF loans, South Korea's linguistic and cultural unity, etc], but it is far-fetched to deny that S. Korea's financial acumen played no role).

The replacement of faith with moral relativity and cynicism also contributes to economic downturns. Without unifying belief in post-death consequences, there is no forceful constraint on behavior when there is pressure to act selfishly. My careful observations confirm that faithful people have more of a stomach to do what is right when nobody is looking. As the priority of religion dwindles in America, I predict that business and finance leaders will be less and less bound by morals and they will have more need of being restricted by economic regulations and criminal laws that will, in turn, burden the full potential of businesses and the finance sector to do good for society. Although a strong moral education and ethical character among leaders will not solve all the complex social risks of finance innovation, it is certainly an important part of the solution.

In short, I would say that the proper course for the United States vis-a-vis the finance industry is two-fold. First, complexity and innovation in finance should be encouraged, but not to such a degree that regulators, shareholders, and legislators can't understand reflect on the implications of the develpments. Regulation should be efficient and not overlapping or over-broad. Second (and the government's role is limited here), religion and traditional values need to have a stronger presence in the lives of Americans. This starts in the home.

Ethics and Inevitability

Sunday, August 26, 2012


                                                                                                                                         Photo: Enoch Lai

It is inevitable that other nations will not enforce American copyrights and patents in violation of their treaties. Is it ethical then for the United States to break its promise and not enforce those countries' copyrights and patents? 


A couple years ago, a controversial scientist testified before Congress that "The development of human cloning is inevitable." If his statement is true, would advocating against human cloning or for restraint be futile? Would it be anti-science? 

It is inevitable that political partisans will use unethical arguments and mudslinging to persuade the weak to their cause. Does that justify using ad hominem and mischaracterization to push a political agenda?

Cheating in school is inevitable. There are a surprising number of students who cheat on college and graduate school entrance exams. Most polls seem to show that a majority of both high school and college students cheat. Since others are getting a leg up, is it ok to level the playing field by cheating?

The answer to all four of these questions is a resounding NO. It is not inherently anti-science or anti-progress to oppose the inevitable. The announcement of inevitability does not signal ethical finality. The assertion of inevitability in ethical disputes is not an appeal to morals at all; it is an effort to abandon ethical considerations altogether.  Just because something will happen does not mean we shouldn't fight against it. Courage is standing for what is right even if you stand alone.

Virtue Politics

Monday, August 6, 2012



Honor is a harder master than the law.

Today, political campaigns seem devoid of moral justifications for their social policies. Instead, politicians mask their foundational beliefs and defend their proposals with mere facial arguments from liberty and equality. While considerations of liberty and equality are relevant and important; alone, they are insufficient defenses for policies regarding abortion, marriage, affirmative action, drugs, immigration, capital punishment, pornography, and a whole gambit of other social issues.

Today, society is increasingly gripped by the notion that religion and moral beliefs have little or no place in the public sphere. Science is supreme. When you debate political issues, you aren’t supposed to defend your views with notions of morality. You are supposed to say how it will affect the economy or how it will affect public health or what will be “fair” in a sort of morally relativistic way. However, science can only inform our decisions; science cannot determine values. But, I say that religious views and moral considerations should be involved in our debates over social policy. When politicians capriciously remove these fundamental beliefs from their speeches and debates and pretend that they have no bearing on their platform, it leaves public deliberations on the issues debilitated. It unilaterally disarms anyone that believes in anything other than liberty of choice or equality as the sole and ultimate objectives of human societies.

Those who claim to be morally neutral do so misleadingly; they hold their moral beliefs so dogmatically that they do not even recognize that they are not really neutral. There can be no political community that is morally neutral. Their vision of a good society is not supported by science but is a moral conviction. The values these people esteem above others (without scientific support) are free self-expression, liberty of choice, or some notion of equality. All good goals, but at the same time, these people cheapen historically ubiquitous virtues like wisdom, courage, kindness, temperance, or transcendence.

What kind of society does this purported neutrality give us? It aims towards a polis that implicitly accepts that there are no right and wrong and no real human virtues. It affords no reverence to tradition. Tolerance and sharing are the only values in such a dispirited society. This intensely individualist sort of social contract would only have the benefit of avoiding religious or moral disputes. But, it aims too low. As society allows room for the basest parts of human nature, evil actions become normalized and acceptable. The saying of the day, “I can do whatever I want so long as it doesn’t hurt anyone else” proves untenable. We cannot do evil without negatively affecting those around us directly or indirectly. People too often underestimate the harm they do to others. Similarly, society underestimates the effect of removing public disapproval of evil.

This disenchanted “neutral” society wherein all we can do is “get along” is not the best we can do. We can strive for a wise, courageous, kind, temperate, and transcendent culture and society. But, we have to be willing to say that these virtues really are better than characteristics like stupidity, guile, selfishness, overindulgence, and corruption and that we will not condone them. And, can we not say that? I am not advocating here a tyranny of the majority where the values of the powerful are always imposed on those less fortunate. Plurality is a wonderful part of American government. However, I am advocating a liberal society moderated and elevated by the traditional and fundamental values we inherited from our founding fathers. We should bring our beliefs to the ballot box with us, but not establish a religion or state indoctrinated moral code. Politicians should be more open and candid about the moral values that undergird their social policy proposals.

Freedom and equality are instrumental in obtaining a virtuous society; they are not the ends in themselves. Let us stop pretending that those values are somehow more scientific or morally neutral than wisdom, courage, kindness, temperance, and transcendence. Virtuous living supersedes the value of cultural diversity (though cultural diversity is certainly to be celebrated). A virtuous society precedes a prosperous one just as a corrupt and decadent society precedes a nation in decline. Facilitating a virtuous society must be the first goal of American politics, then freedom and equality.

Heterophobes and Fried Chicken

Friday, August 3, 2012

                                                                                  Photo: Port Charlotte NJROTC

Dan Cathy, Chick-Fil-A's Baptist President and Chief Operating Officer, is not sheepish about expressing his support for traditional marriage. His father founded the successful fast-food chain and fostered a corporate culture based on Christian beliefs. The chain is closed on Sundays and, not surprisingly, the President and faithful Baptist supports traditional marriage and opposes same-sex marriage. 

Demonstrating blatant disrespect for freedom of speech, the Mayors of Chicago, Boston, Washington D.C., and San Francisco have announced that Chick-Fil-A is not welcome in their cities. They claim that Chick-Fil-A values are not their cities' values and that they might well attempt to block Chick-Fil-A from opening up new locations in their cities. 

The Mayors' threats are obviously a political ploy. No one could take an attempt to block a new Chick-Fil-A location too seriously. The ACLU says the Mayor's threats constitute a "constitutional problem with discriminating against someone based on the content of their speech.” It is unconstitutional to block strip clubs; obviously it is unconstitutional to block a restaurant chain. Although I don't imagine very many people consider the Mayors' threats seriously, the vignette of politics brings to light a serious problem with policy debate in America. The problem is that many secularists and same-sex marriage advocates push their agenda primarily with ad hominem and hostility rather than addressing the scientific, philosophical, ethical, political, psychological, and religious arguments of their opponents. These advocates are quick to cry "bigot" and "oppression" at anyone's suggestion that same-sex marriage may have negative policy effects or if anyone shows discomfort with the notion of same-sex marriage. These are the same advocates that use vague expressions of diversity and tolerance as their primary argument. Yet, too many attack their opponents rather than their opponents' arguments. Their strategy is no longer to convince the other side but to embarrass, shut out, and shut up their opponents through mudslinging and name-calling. 

The Roman Catholic Church also opposes same-sex marriage. They also operate many of the largest and most efficient charities in the world. Are their values not Chicago's values? Will radical same-sex marriage advocates boycott the charities? Individuals are free to do so. But, for politicians to use their position to attack organizations and individuals because of their political beliefs (especially those shared by half the population) seems to go too far in itself. But, threatening to do clearly unconstitutional actions is, wow. 

The public discourse is eroded when fallacies like ad hominem are employed in the place of arguments of real substance. Unfortunately, playing on peoples fears and needs of acceptance works. Many people are not trained to think critically about what they hear. However, to coerce by threats of hate and rejection rather than to try and honestly and intelligently convince the opposing side is immoral and hostile to the democratic process. Our discourse about policy should not be modeled after cable news political commentary, which is a parade of confirmation bias and vitriol. Yes, it sells. But, no it is not good for public discourse. Rather, we should try to model our debate and discourse after academic discourse which is more self-examined, honest, comprehensive, and helpful. Perhaps, our discourse should allow emotion and religion more of a place than it has in academic literature. But the mature respect for the opposing side where reasonable minds differ should be present in public discourse as it is in scholastic debate.


Critique of the Supreme Court's Healthcare Decision

Monday, July 2, 2012



Last week, the United States Supreme Court held that the Affordable Healthcare Act's ("Act") individual mandate, although unconstitutional under the Commerce Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause was constitutional under the Taxing and Spending Clause. I disagree for two reasons. First, the "[s]hared responsibility payment" exacted from those who do not buy health insurance does not fall under the Taxing and Spending Clause because its primary purpose is to alter behavior and not to raise revenue. If there is to be any distinction between taxes and penalties, surely it is that taxes raise revenue first and alter behavior second while penalties alter behavior primarily and raise revenue as a plus. Second, to the extent that Justice Roberts ruled the way he did to protect the legitimacy of the court, he did exactly the opposite. The Supreme Court is to interpret the law; not to engage in politics and protect the legitimacy of the Court in the eyes of the public. By deciding issues not on their merits, but on public opinion, in fact, diminishes the legitimacy of the court. Besides, the Act, and especially the individual mandate, is very unpopular.

The Affordable Healthcare Act intends to increase healthcare coverage and lower insurance premiums. Currently, federal laws require hospitals to care for people regardless of whether they have insurance or not. See, e.g. 42 U.S.C. 1395(d)(d). This creates a free-rider problem that the Act seeks to avoid by making sure everyone gets insurance or pays their own way. The Act makes a number of other changes in the current healthcare system too. It requires insurers to provide policies to those with most preexisting conditions (excluding tobacco use) and prohibits insurers from discriminating against those with preexisting conditions. Medicaid is extended to cover all people under 133% of the federal poverty level ($14, 856 for an individual) and subsidizes insurance for families making up to 400% the poverty level. The overall objective is praiseworthy; but the execution is lamentable.

Although I like the provision requiring insurers to cover preexisting conditions, I do not think preexisting conditions that are caused by an individual's poor choices should be treated equally as preexisting conditions that are someone else's fault, an act of fate, or genetic. Although I want to get rid of free riders too, there are other ways to do that. Perhaps mandate employers to cover their employees and create an unemployment program. Perhaps let the states figure it out on their own. Perhaps create a public/private balance by providing a limited-public healthcare (preventative care and emergency services only) that is restricted so as to allow private hospitals to thrive.

Chief Justice Roberts, writing for the majority, was correct in determining that the individual mandate is unconstitutional under the Commerce Clause. The Commerce Clause regulates commerce and gives Congress only the right to regulate commercial activities. If an activity does not endanger another's fundamental rights and is not commercial in nature, it is generally outside the regulation power of Congress. The individual mandate does not purport to regulate existing commercial activity but attempts to coerce people into the market.

My contention with the Chief Justice has to do with his notion that the "shared responsibility payment" is a tax rather than a penalty. Unlike Congress' other powers, the taxing and spending power is unlimited. As long as the government is primarily spending its revenues or raising revenues it can do whatever it likes. If it wanted, Congress could institute a national bake sale in an effort to raise a lot of dough. Essentially, Justice Roberts says that unless legislation is unavoidably unconstitutional, then judges should decide to uphold the legislation and respect the democratic process. Justice Roberts believes that to call the shared responsibility payment a tax is plausible and thus, to protect the democratic process, you have to agree that it is a tax. I disagree. Unless the construction truly is 50/50 ambiguous, a judges job is to interpret the law and call it how the preponderance of the evidence points. Justice Roberts is changing the evidentiary standard for civil cases without giving any meaningful explanation as to why.

Additionally, I do not think calling it a tax is reasonable. Many people call it a tax for political reasons; but they don't call it that because there is anything more than the slightest whim to suggest that the fee is a tax. Taxing is to raise revenue (see, e.g. Rev. Rul. 79-180); penalties incentivize affirmative behavior. Penalties have a wag your finger feeling to them. Taxes do not. Even the name of the penalty, "shared responsibility payment" implies that it is a penalty to incentivize responsible behavior. If it were a tax, it would be called the "economic offset payment" or something. The act itself even refers to the payment as a "penalty." Is there any question that Congress intended this to be a penalty? To call this a tax is to both distort the plain definition of tax and rewrite the statute to be something it was not. Chief Justice Roberts says government has called fees that are supposed to change behavior taxes before (like cigarette taxes). However, such taxes are commercial in nature or are constitutional under other provisions of the Constitution. The taxes Justice Roberts refers to seek to regulate activities that are commercial or activities that negatively effect others' liberties. It seems that the Chief Justice arbitrarily defines a penalty as fines that are unbearable or enforced by criminal institutions. Hardly an intuitive definition.

It is also curious that Chief Justice Roberts considers the penalty a penalty for purposes of the Anti-Injunction Act but a tax for other legal purposes without any real explanation. No one saw that contortion of logic coming; not even the lawyers arguing for the mandate.

The reading of the Court allows Congress to force people to buy anything on threat of getting a penalty (oops, I mean "tax"). Congress can now use the Taxing and Spending Clause all alone to force citizens to buy healthy food, bus tickets, funeral insurance, gymnastics lessons, etc. We are now less free than we were last week and the limited powers of the Federal government as intended by the Framers are less limited. We are being lulled into soft tyranny, trading our American autonomy for paternalistic and ostensible comforts and entitlements.

And what of the 10th Amendment that reserves all unlisted powers to the states? To deny states all medicaid funding if they do not implement the plan is surely so substantial as to amount to coercion against the 10th Amendment. Let the states come up with their own solutions.

The most important judicial precedent is original understanding. While we may depart from original understanding through Constitutional Amendments or enormously deliberate popular action, to depart from the original understanding of the Constitution to such an extent and on such a flimsy whim is a tragic disrespect to the miracle of the Constitution.





Reaction to President Obama's Support of Same-Sex Marriage

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

President Obama announced yesterday on ABC News that he now affirmatively supports legalizing gay marriage. He mentioned that his Christian faith and the golden rule lie at the foundation of his decision. In my opinion, the interviewer, Robin Roberts, failed to ask him the obvious tough follow up questions. I watched an hour of coverage of the issue on CNN and they had not one commentator on the other side of the issue except for one blurb from an AME reverend who, in essence, said that although he disagrees with the President's decision everyone should still vote for him. Anyway, that is an aside. This assertion implies that the President buys in to one of four beliefs that would justify his new found support for gay marriage: (1) gay marriage is a moral issue and same-sex marriage is moral, (2) gay marriage is a moral issue and regardless of his own personal view, government endorsement of same-sex marriage is fine, (3) gay marriage is not a moral issue, or (4), the most cynical, that he believes it is a good political bet and that making insincere statements to get reelected is ok.

If the President accepts (1) or (3) his ideology becomes even more masked than before. He used his religious beliefs, Christianity, to justify his decision. That invites skepticism. Doesn't the Bible condemn sex outside of opposite-gender marriage across the board? Isn't sex outside of traditional marriage a moral issue in all of the major monotheistic religions? How could defining marriage not be moral? If it is moral were Moses, Paul, and other prophets wrong when they implicitly and explicitly denounced gay marriage and sex outside of opposite-sex marriage? Shopping cart Christians and fearful believers efforts to reconcile the growing popular support for gay marriage with doctrine have, in my view, failed. I have heard reporters say that Christian churches are behind the times; but, what they don't understand is that the doctrine and principles of Christianity are neither behind nor ahead of the times-- they transcend time. However, they find little historical support and are controversial at least. While supporting (1) might not be totally out of left field, I hope some commentator will push him to really say why he believes that.

The second assertion (2) bugs me because it takes moral debate out of the public policy. It endorses moral relativism and libertinism. It invites market theory to control things within the moral realm. Although money may not be involved, believing (2) says "I think we should keep our conversation shallow and never address the moral and religious foundations of our beliefs. Popularity and not wisdom should drive our policy."

Finally, (4) is, in my view,  corrupt. 'Nuff said.

Defining marriage is clearly a moral issue. Although individuals might be unable to entirely control their feelings, they can control their actions. We are all born with trials. Policy should reflect the ideal of children being raised by their biological parents who are committed to a forever relationship and teamwork. Marriage as a legal sanctioning of personal commitment or of love is only part of the equation.