Showing posts with label Entitlements. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Entitlements. Show all posts

Equality of Opportunity and Equality of Outcome

Tuesday, October 2, 2012



There are two notions of equality that drive different political ideologies. The first is equality of opportunity. An equality of opportunity approach seeks to level the playing field by making the law apply equally to everyone. The second kind of equality is equality of outcomes. Equality of outcomes seeks to ensure that everyone ends up in the same conditions. The two are mutually exclusive to some degree as equality of opportunity implies certain inequality of outcome. Only equality of opportunity is consistent with pure liberty. But, what kind of “equality of opportunity” should we seek in America? And, is the line between the two as clear as one might like to think?

Let’s look at a case study of affirmative action. The issue is obviously complex and some oversimplification will unfortunately be necessary to fit this into a neat little blog post. Racial inequality is measurable by educational indicators, socio-economic circumstances, crime rates, single mothers, and by a number of other sociological gauges. To correct for these inequalities, various affirmative action policies have been put into effect. Affirmative action policies can perhaps be grouped into two primary types. First, there are systematic remedies that seek to level the playing field and make the rules apply to everyone the same. Secondly, there are redistributive policies that seek to open up new opportunities.

What would justify affirmative action? Presumably, most all affirmative action policies would be unjustifiable if racial inequality arises from (1) innate biological inferiority (overwhelming evidence refutes this notion entirely); (2) cultural pathologies that deemphasize hard work, education, etc (some empirical evidence supports this); or (3) voluntary choices to pursue the paths that they do (very unlikely). However, what affirmative action policies are justified if (a) discrimination and stereotypes play a role in keeping a race down (informal barriers) or (b) structural based obstacles like segregation or a lack of family connections work against a race (formal barriers)?

Even libertarians think that structural or systematic obstacles stemming from government’s duplicitous treatment of different races should be abolished. But, to the extent that discrimination (overt and unconscious) still exists, should quotas, recruiting campaigns, or employee support programs be provided to members of a disadvantaged race? Although express quotas in hiring and school admissions are prohibited by law, unspoken redistributions of opportunity in many careers and school admissions are measurable statistically and legal. So, should discrimination be remedied by redistributions of opportunities? Such an approach would be an equality of outcomes approach. 

Affirming a belief in equality of opportunity implies a belief that government should make sure everyone starts off in the same place, not that everyone ends up in the same condition. However, the issue is complicated by the fact that people aren’t born in the same place. Although we are all of equal value in the eyes of our Heavenly Father, some of us are born to poor parents, others to rich parents; some are born in the United States, others in Somalia; some to parents who love one another, others never know one of their parents; etc. The only way to get everyone started off equally would be to institute some Spartan program of community child-rearing and a total prohibition of any gifts whether given inter vivos or after death. However, that just seems inherently wrong and completely inconsistent with freedom.

Should we simply ignore birth inequalities? I am tempted to say that it is better to let mysterious fate distribute opportunity rather than the arbitrary or fleeting preferences of government. But, I don’t think such an extreme view is the only answer to this puzzle.

A certain degree of economic inequality is desirable. Inequality provides rewards for hard work, talent, and achievement. It provides lubricant for social enterprise and progress. However, when inequality becomes too great, it animates pride, exploitation, discontent, and rebellion that cause societal decline. When crafting solutions to inequality, government should not focus on where to strike a balance between inequality and equality. Rather, I think the focus should be on balancing economic mobility with the freedom to bequest good things to our loved ones. That isn’t very precise; but I don’t think precise is possible. The slightest possibility of reaching the top of the Forbes Richest People list in a single lifetime is all that is necessary for proper income mobility in my view. 

I am thus only in favor of redistributive policies to the extent that all people have the minimum necessities of education, food, shelter, medical care, and life guidance to change their own fortunes and achieve unlimited success with the probabilities of economic success (for full-time, committed individuals mid-career) being chartable on a bell curve. With a more virtuous society, the bell curve will shift towards the prosperous; with a society in moral decline will shift towards the poor. But, the possibility to succeed or to lose should always be present. Real freedom can only be present if we are responsible for the consequences of our choices.

Given my acceptance of some forms of redistributive policies, it is worth mentioning that such policies have been egregiously mismanaged. First, the government not only redistributes things that are not the minimum necessities I described, but are actually detrimental to a disadvantaged person's chances of improving his or her situation. People don’t need a T.V. In fact, TVs do more damage than good. Somehow, people on government stipends for poverty, unemployment, etc afford televisions. People don’t need more bedrooms than there are people in their family; yet I see that in my service to those in government subsidized (or furnished) housing.  And, even the things government provides that people do need as minimum necessities are mismanaged on a large scale. Student loans are given in excessive amounts and without any risk assessment. Medicare pays for unnecessary stuff and pays more for the same services when compared to Veteran Affairs. Redundant programs (there are 23 agencies that provide independent and overlapping assistance to former USSR countries, 12 agencies that ensure food safety requirements are met, and the list goes on for a very long time) are the norm. The mismanagement of what should be proper government redistribution and regulation purposes cannot be understated.

I should also say that income mobility is not the most important thing in the world. Even people who end up not able to break through their birth social class can live joyful and meaningful lives. Indeed, the rich are often less happy, probably because they focus too much on money and too little on the more important things of life like faith, family, friends, and developing an honorable and virtuous character. Equality and freedom are instrumental in bringing forth a virtuous society. But, neither is the end in itself. Government policies should reflect that emphasis on virtuous living through freedom and equality rather than freedom and equality at the expense of virtue.





Federalism: Commerce + Elastic Clauses vs. 10th Amendment

Thursday, March 1, 2012



One of the crowning features of the American Constitution is federalism. Splitting the atom of national sovereignty vertically between the states and federal government affords Americans many benefits. Firstly, it guards against tyranny. Montesquieu and James Madison both defined tyranny as the accumulation of powers all in the same unified entity (Federalist #47). Keeping authority and powers separated between local and national government discourages the abuse of power and protects the rights of regional minorities. Secondly, federalism facilitates the general principle of subsidiarity which holds that matters should be handled on the lowest organizational level possible. Regional governments are closer and more invested in their jurisdiction and can better respond to local needs and preferences. Federalism tends to result in improved economic effectiveness. Thirdly, federalism allows for experimentation as the states innovate and test new policies.

Originally, even the founding fathers who advocated for a strong federal government believed that the states would retain substantial sovereignty. Madison said, "The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite." Until very recently, however, the federal government has consistently expanded its powers to the diminution of the powers of the states. It is the natural tendency for any governmental entity to try and amplify its influence; however, their actions at the fringes of their power must make it through the gates of judicial review.

One of the enumerated powers of Congress is to "regulate Commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes." Although, in its infancy, the Commerce Clause was given a narrow interpretation of "trade," the Supreme Court now interprets "Commerce" more broadly to include production, manufacturing, trade, and even wholly intrastate economic activities which "substantially effect" interstate commerce. The latter meaning is set in precedent, but certainly stretches the original understanding of the term considerably.

The Constitution also empowers Congress "To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof." The Necessary and Proper Clause has caused political friction since its inception. Thomas Jefferson thought that "Necessary" referred only to those things that were indispensible. Thus, in his mind, the federal government could exercise only its enumerated powers and the means to accomplishing those powers as absolutely necessary. John Adams, on the other hand, believed that this was an untenable position that would result in an impuissant federal government unable to provide for the well-being of its citizens. Adam's view won the day and since McCulloch v. Maryland (1819), the Supreme Court has read "Necessary" to mean "convenient" or "useful" for some political end. The Court, however, does not question the validity of acts of Congress as long as such acts have some plausible explanation or purpose behind the legislation.

The Commerce Clause combined with the Necessary and Proper Clause makes for wide discretion and power on behalf of the federal government and gives reason for continually diminishing the powers reserved for the states. The current Court has said that this combination is not without limit as other Supreme Courts seemed to have implied. In United States v. Lopez, the Court held that the Commerce Clause extended only to economic activities. In the past decade, the Court has also limited the federal expansion by asserting that the 10th Amendment also buts up against the Commerce Clause. There are various opinions about this. The 10th Amendment states, "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." On one end of the spectrum, there are people that hold this Amendment to be only a truism. They believe that the states only have the leftover powers that the federal government leaves behind, which could be nothing. Others say no, no, the states obviously have some essential function in the Constitution and the federal government cannot grow to the point that it infringes on that essential constitutional role. On the other extreme end of the spectrum are those that believe the federal government should be severely restricted to its enumerated powers alone.

I believe American federalism is an exalted principle of our miraculous Constitution. While I am a firm believer in the free market, I am not totally opposed to federal involvement and regulation. But, Congress too often overreacts to public tragedies and enact regulations to please the public and add ephemeral popular causes to their curriculum vitae. The result is overregulation and legislation that is hastily pushed through. The United States currently has over 240 regulatory agencies. The Federal Register (containing executive agencies regulations) is nearly 83,000 pages long (Obama's administration has added around 15,000 pages so far). Whereas before there was only a handful of federal crimes and the states were left to deal with crime, now there are over 4,000 federal crimes, but no one knows exactly how many there are because of the way they are cross-referenced with regulations. Too many federal laws and regulations are either unnecessary or detrimental; too many are overlapping with the each other or with state regulations that are doing a fine enough job.

Legislation should be approached carefully and deliberately. Here are a few things legislatures should consider before enacting any new law or regulation scheme:

(1) How much would the subject of legislation or regulation benefit from economies of scale. Sometimes, it is more effective to do something once on a grand scale than to do it 50 times. For example, the NASA space program would likely be impossible if every state pursued it on their own. But, together, much more is possible.

(2) Is the issue of great, lasting, and communal importance or is it a matter of local needs, preferences, and conditions? Building codes and speed limits, for example, have little or no effect on the nation as a whole and are better established by local governments.

(3) Is there a collective-action problem resulting in a race to the bottom when all the states are left on their own to devise policy and solutions? Or, is there incentive to race to the top? Does competitiveness and free market lead to positive outcomes or does it lead to free riders and states trying to undercut each other?

(4) Does allowing states to legislate and regulate in a particular area cause negative externalities? If Illinois decides to engage in manufacturing that severely pollutes the Mississippi River, at least five other states are going to suffer.

(5) How sure are we of a regulation or legislative scheme's effectiveness? Has it been proven in the laboratories of the states? States experiment with new policies that sometimes work and are adopted by other states. For example, medical marijuana in California, a Unicameral legislature in Nebraska, or a 4-day state government business week in Utah are all being watched by other states to see how things work out.

(6) Are maintenance, monitoring, and enforcement costs cheaper at the state or national level?

(7) Is legislation and regulation the most effective way to deal with a problem or would tort law be more cost-effective? So many expensive regulations are unnecessary because Tort Law (or Contract or Property) has proven itself more cost-effective and equally as efficient.

(8) Is there a restraint on Americans' individual agency and liberty? Will Americans have less choices because of a new regulation or law? If so, is a (often marginal) increase in security worth the loss of freedom? Remember, "Give me liberty or give me death?" It seems Americans are too easily lulled into saying, "Here's some more of my liberty, can you make me more secure (even if the policy is more like a sugar pill)?