Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Government. Show all posts

On Big Stores and Advertising

Saturday, May 11, 2013


Earnest Hemmingway wrote in his memoir, “If you are lucky enough to have lived in Paris as a young man, then wherever you go for the rest of your life it stays with you, for Paris is a moveable feast.” I agree completely. Not a day goes by that I do not think back fondly on my years walking the historic and fashionable streets of Paris. France left me with the indelible conviction that life is better when society is not so obnoxiously full of huge chain stores and pervasive advertising. Although the United States should avoid many Western European policies like the plague, we should follow their example by helping small shops and regulating manipulative, in-your-face advertising. Corporate stores and rampant advertising contribute to a materialistic culture and an undesirable physical environment, both of which are enemies of American spiritual, emotional, and physical wellbeing. Our American Dream should be about the contributions we will make to our families and to society, not about the stuff we buy.

Big Corporate Chain Stores

There are fewer and fewer small consumer-oriented businesses left in America. We buy our Chinese-manufactured clothing from chain stores. We buy our genetically modified groceries at chain stores. We buy our furniture from chain stores. Same goes with our electronics, hardware, beauty supplies, and sports equipment. Although there are a few Ma & Pa restaurants and shops around, we buy almost everything from big corporations. I dislike shopping at big chain shops because the quality of products and service is poor. There is a plausible argument that big chain stores are cheaper and more convenient than shopping at small shops. I generally disagree; but the argument is intelligent. However, that big corporations put out better quality products and services than small shops, nobody has even begun to prove. Owners of small shops take greater pride in their services and products. Products are higher quality when they are made by a particular craftsman for a particular customer. Unfortunately, many Americans have become habituated to poor quality products—plastics, wax, and cheap construction are everywhere. Similarly, small service providers tend to outdo their corporate counterparts.
I’d like to briefly address the arguments that big chain stores are better because they are cheaper and more convenient. Products are generally cheaper at big stores, but their duration is shorter, which costs more. For example, a tailored suit will be more comfortable, look better, and last longer than a mass-produced, cheap suit. It is very possible that the a man would have to buy two or three cheap suits to dress himself for the same amount of time that the tailor-made suit will last him. Big stores are probably cheaper than small stores to some extent, but much less than many Americans seem to think. If there were much fewer big shops around, shopping at little shops would be more convenient than shopping at the big places. It isn’t much more convenient to walk the length of a street in the same store; you might as well walk the same distance from little shop to little shop. Since all of our stores are huge nowadays, we have to travel longer distances to get what we need. If shops were smaller, we would be better able to walk to buy our food and supplies rather than have to drive—healthier, more sociable, and generally more pleasant.
I have found that many people do not know that public corporations are required by law to put the pecuniary interests of shareholders before all interests of consumers. Frequently, pleasing customers translates into increased profits, but not always. Big corporations wield their influence over government and society to make their job easier and more lucrative. They use their power to make things more convenient to make money, not more convenient for the consumer. They get customers addicted to a product or service and then decrease the quality with time. As a result, frivolous consumerism is way too much a part of American culture. The companies convince people that they need more stuff, not better stuff. The corporations convince people that they need things, they don’t really need. The corporations use advertising to teach people to envy others for their things and to feel like they are inadequate if they don’t keep up with the Joneses. It is even rather rare for critiques of corporate stores to show up in reputable publications because they are hesitant about publishing anything that will offend their sponsors.
In my opinion, this consumerism is exemplified by smartphone buying. I know a few people who spend exorbitant amounts to constantly upgrade from the iPhone 3GS, to the iPhone 4, to the iPhone 4S, and for what? Finicky voice-recognition software? A slightly improved camera? More likely, it is to keep up with the Joneses because they have fallen prey to the corporation’s message that your phone is a status symbol. Or, they have convinced them, through sly psychological trickery that stuff makes them happier than it actually does; that things are better than time. Despite all of the freedom and money we have in America, we are not the happiest people because we are too stressed about things that don’t matter. We need to stop spending our resources on stuff and status and start spending them on enjoying our family, nature, and culture—for that is where real happiness lies.
Additionally, the growth of big corporate stores concentrates wealth in the hands of fewer and fewer citizens. Some of my friends who disagree with my sentiment here argue that I am going against the free market. I am not so sure that I am—but, perhaps I am to a degree. I measure the value of the free market first by its ability to bring about a good society and secondarily by its ability to maximize wealth and American political power. Regardless, I think that these big chain stores are engaging in anticompetitive activity by elbowing out their competitors with an onslaught of manipulative advertising, political influence (e.g. procuring favorable changes in the tax structure, business regulation, etc.), and even pushing urban designs that favor big stores over little ones, even to the detriment of city beauty and the health of the environment.
Some businesses perhaps provide more public good to us as Americans if they are big. I do not doubt it. This essay is not against all big natural resources, pharmaceutical, manufacturing companies, etc. What I am convinced of is that quality of life is better when there are more SMALL SHOPS than there are corporate mega-chains. Having a few big stores is fine. But, the proliferation of corporate chain stores has weakened local economies, stripped communities of their beauty and character, and impoverished civic and cultural life in American towns and cities. 

Advertising

But wait, there’s more! We are practically drowning in the manipulative marketing of big shops. I have tried American-style advertising for free and I want to return it for a full refund. The trial was definitely not risk-free. It was fraught with puffery, misleading information, psychological chicanery, and false portrayals of reality. The ubiquitous nature of the loud and bright advertising is so constant that it fatigues you and pounces when you are too tired to adequately defend against its cunning attacks. You see, advertising works. It sells. But, it is annoying and bad for America on a cultural and moral level. Even the advertisements online are worse in the United States. They are more common, more in-your-face, brighter, and cheesier.
In my opinion, the only proper purpose of advertising is to inform people of their options with regard to products and services. Advertising in America is, to some degree, protected by the First Amendment and is backed by big-time support of lobbyists; but we need more truthful advertising, fewer commercials, fewer ugly billboards, and fewer product placements in the media. We need to emphasize America’s natural beauty and family values by making the places we live and the activities we engage in supportive of those things. 

Guns, Crime, and Statistics

Saturday, January 19, 2013



Psychologically, humans have difficulty making sense of data. Although we are talented associative, causative, and analogous thinkers, cognitive science has abundantly demonstrated that we have trouble thinking statistically. For example, most people incorrectly believe politicians have more extra-marital affairs than doctors. Why? Because, thanks to the news, they associate politicians with scandals. Indeed, even the way statistics are framed can drastically change our perception. Doctors are more likely to operate on patients if they are told there is a 90% survival rate than if they are told there is a 10% mortality rate. In my observations of the recent gun control debate, I have noticed a lot of flawed statistical reasoning. But, with so many numbers being thrown out, it is hard to make sense of the data. I decided to spend an hour looking over gun and crime statistics to see if I could start to make any sense of them. Here are my thoughts.

Moral Assumptions about Gun Ownership

            The Second Amendment guarantees the right of citizens to “keep and bear arms.” The Supreme Court has interpreted the phrase to mean, essentially, “possess and own non-military weapons.”  Although many argue that the Second Amendment only applies to militia members and others go even further to assert that a right to gun ownership is antiquated, I think both arguments are wrong. Before and after the Constitution was ratified, militias were composed of private citizens who owned and carried their own guns. Indeed, a number of states were told they were voting for individual, private ownership of guns when the Second Amendment was up for ratification. So, it doesn’t seem to make much sense to say that private citizens can’t own or carry weapons unless furnished by an official military unit. Private gun ownership was firmly entrenched in the American tradition and went unchallenged for about a century.
I believe gun ownership is beneficial today for three reasons: (1) it allows private citizens to protect their lives and property; (2) it disincentivizes against oppressive government conduct and strengthens our military; (3) it represents the value we place on freedom in America. According to the FBI, one in about every 250 Americans will be murdered (assuming current murder rates) and the likelihood of being involved in violent crime or robbery is even higher. The likelihood of dying in an accidental firearm discharge is one in 4,888 (and many of these are from hunting and target shooting accidents outside of the home). It might make some sense to require a gun safe in the home, but these numbers suggest owning a gun is more likely to protect you than to hurt you. Although I think foreign invasion or a coup d’état is extremely unlikely in the United States, I think the slow erosion of our rights in exchange for false security is likely. Gun ownership is symbolic to our freedom and discourages rash government intrusion. In addition, our military is disproportionately made up of people who grew up with guns in the home. I think it fair to say that our military, especially in case of an unexpected need for a draft, is all the stronger for it.
However, I am not one to say, “Guns don’t kill people. People kill people.” Although violent crime is much more a function of mental health, racial demographics, socio-economic factors, and family stability than it is about gun ownership, the easy availability of guns has some effect. Whether easy availability of guns is 2%, 10%, or 30% of the cause of violent crime, I don’t know. Although gun sales and ownership is up by about 5% since 2001, gun murders, gun aggravated assault, and gun robbery have all gone down during the same time frame. Clearly, other contributing factors are more an issue than gun sales and ownership. Although mass murders in upper and middle class America draw the most attention, they represent only a tiny segment of murders nationwide. The majority of murders are concentrated in less advantaged urban neighborhoods and carried out with standard handguns, blunt objects, knives, or hands and feet. Poverty, education, and race are all more predictive of violent crime than is gun ownership. Perhaps gun restrictions should be focused on urban (democratic? Just kidding, but seriously) neighborhoods. Although we lament the horrifying acts of violence at Sandy Hook Elementary, should we not also grieve for the thousands of murders that don’t make national news? Despite my support for some gun regulation measures, I am not particularly emphatic of any because I feel our time and effort could be better spent addressing family stability and socio-economic disparity.
Anyway, with that, I wanted to comment very briefly on a few of President Obama’s legislative proposals for gun regulation.
           
Ban on Assault Weapons and High-Capacity Magazines

            Assault weapons are inconvenient for criminals because they are too bulky for easy concealment. In 2009, rifles were used in 349 murders. Likely only a tiny percentage of rifle murders were carried out with "assault" rifles, which happen to be some of the best selling guns in the country.  Most Americans do not know what an assault rifle is. The distinction between a "regular" rifle and an "assault" rifle isn't the lethality, but the cosmetic features. The difference between a semi-automatic hunting rifle and an assault weapon is not the size of bullet, firing rate, or lethal range. Rather, the difference is whether a gun has a pistol grip, flash hider, or an adjustable shoulder stocks. Assault rifles may have menacing looks, but there is no meaningful distinction between a semi-automatic “assault weapon” and a hunting rifle. The DOJ supposes that assault rifles account for, at most, 2% of gun crimes and that the effects of a ban would be so small as to represent statistical insignificance. The burden on freedom is not de minimis. Really, the ban on assault rifles is only symbolic. It has virtually no affect on crime rates, but represents a step towards more intrusive gun control.


             Bans on high-capacity magazines are similarly symbolic. Such a ban was in place until 2004, when the law expired. Crime rates lowered at predictable rates without the magazine ban lapse even registering as a statistical blip. Indeed, a number of mass murders, including the Columbine High School Massacre and the Virginia Tech Shooting were perpetrated with low-capacity magazines without sacrificing any malicious efficiency.  This legislative proposal is more about eroding freedoms with a false lullaby of security than it is about actually saving lives; therefore I oppose this measure.

Requiring Background Checks on All Gun Sales

I support background checks on gun sales as long as they don’t cause unreasonable inconvenience on the buyer. To the extent that the purchaser does not have to fill out unnecessary paperwork, wait an undue amount of time, or wade through sticky bureaucracy—I think background checks on all gun sales will have a more beneficial affect than the minor any minor inconvenience. I would even consider a national gun registry—so long as it wasn’t being used as symbolic warfare on gun ownership generally.

Stricter Penalties for Assisting Criminals and Felons to Obtain Guns

            Tough penalties on illegal gun trafficking and crimes are a step in the right direction. However, deterrence is better accomplished by increasing the likelihood of getting caught than by increasing the severity of the punishment. We need more undercover cops and less cozy prisons.

Strong Families

President Obama is not suggesting this as a solution to violent crime. But, more than anything, we need strong families for a secure and free society. Single-parent homes, high-divorce rates, sex out of wedlock, diminished involvement in community organizations, and drugs in the home are the driving factors of poor educational outcomes, high crime, and socio-economic disparity. Crafting policies to support strong families would do more for lowering gun crime than regulating guns would lower gun crime.

Capital Gains Overview

Tuesday, November 20, 2012



INTRODUCTION-- WHAT ARE CAPITAL GAINS?

With all the recent talk about Mitt Romney's taxes and the impending "fiscal cliff," I realized that I, as well as many people, had only a rudimentary understanding of the taxation of capital gains. Indeed, I feel many retain some misinformation on the topic.

Long-term capital assets receive preferential tax treatment under the Internal Revenue Code. Long-term capital assets are any property held for more than a year EXCEPT for property that is the normal source of business income (e.g. inventory held for sale, business equipment, office space, etc.). Perhaps the most familiar form of capital gains are those associated with stock in companies. For those realizing capital gains whose marginal tax rate is 15% or lower, they pay NO tax on capital gains (0%). For those in higher tax brackets, capital gains are taxed at a maximum rate of 15%. However, the rates on capital gains are slated to go up to 20% on December 31, 2012 unless Congress does something to change it (part of the "fiscal cliff").

PROS & CONS OF PREFERENTIAL TAX TREATMENT ON CAPITAL GAINS

Justifications advanced for the preferential treatment of long-term capital assets are generally threefold:

1. Part of the gain realized on the sale of capital assets represents inflation. Thus, although the market price of property increases after ten years, the true value has not after factoring in inflation. Taxes should be lower on capital gains to take inflation into account.

2. Lower taxes on capital gains incentivizes responsible savings. 

3. Preferential tax treatment of capital gains makes for mobile capital and more efficient markets. Lower taxes on capital gains makes it easier for investors to take money out of stagnant or failing companies and put it into more promising businesses. Lower capital gains taxes helps socially beneficial or popular enterprises raise capital.

But, there are strong counterarguments too:

1. Differentiating gains and losses as capital or ordinary requires complex and hard to understand regulations. The administration of preferential treatment of capital gains, this argument goes, is too expensive and cumbersome to be worth it. Opponents of lower taxes on capital gains argue that there are better ways to accomplish the purposes of favorable capital gains treatment. For example, tax bases can be adjusted for inflation. 

2. The strongest repost of opponents is that favoring capital gains is just not fair. Only those with lots of capital with which to invest have capital gains. In 2010, the top 1% of income earners realized over 70% of the capital gains.

SOME SUGGESTIONS FOR CHANGE

Regressive Capital Gains Tax: Clayton Christiansen of the Harvard Business School, and others, suggest taxing capital gains regressively over time. In other words, the longer you hold on to an investment, the lower the tax rate should be on that investment. He believes that the relatively minor loss in tax revenues for the government ($38 billion in 2012) are well worth the increase in capital available for job creation and innovation. Indeed, many or probably most economists agree that lower capital gains increase revenues in the long run through quickened economic growth. But, this notion is challenged. The true effects of high and low capital gains rates are hard to measure because there are so many other historical factors that affect the state of the economy. Evidence seems to support and deny the benefits of low taxes on capital gains.

No Capital Gains Tax: There are many voices calling for the government to stop collecting taxes on capital gains entirely. This would have effects on businesses' choice of entity (i.e. pass-through entities like LLC or LPs may lose importance) which may require some legislative tweaking; but, would increase capital mobility and, in theory, make for a more efficient market.

No Preferential Treatment for Capital Gains: Another option would be to tax all gains at the ordinary rates. Whether a gain is realized on stock or through lending services, the tax on income would be the same. This would raise government revenues and make for more equality and result in more fairness. After all, why should income from labor be taxed more than income from investments in big corporations.

Comprehensive Change: Perhaps my idea would be to alter the entire structure of the Code. I would widen the base and flatten the taxes for all but those making more than $5 million per year except for income from patent and copyright royalties. The rate could then be steeper from there. I would do away with a number of counterproductive tax subsidies. I would cut spending and regulation. Perhaps I will elaborate my nascent tax plan in a forthcoming post. 

Equality of Opportunity and Equality of Outcome

Tuesday, October 2, 2012



There are two notions of equality that drive different political ideologies. The first is equality of opportunity. An equality of opportunity approach seeks to level the playing field by making the law apply equally to everyone. The second kind of equality is equality of outcomes. Equality of outcomes seeks to ensure that everyone ends up in the same conditions. The two are mutually exclusive to some degree as equality of opportunity implies certain inequality of outcome. Only equality of opportunity is consistent with pure liberty. But, what kind of “equality of opportunity” should we seek in America? And, is the line between the two as clear as one might like to think?

Let’s look at a case study of affirmative action. The issue is obviously complex and some oversimplification will unfortunately be necessary to fit this into a neat little blog post. Racial inequality is measurable by educational indicators, socio-economic circumstances, crime rates, single mothers, and by a number of other sociological gauges. To correct for these inequalities, various affirmative action policies have been put into effect. Affirmative action policies can perhaps be grouped into two primary types. First, there are systematic remedies that seek to level the playing field and make the rules apply to everyone the same. Secondly, there are redistributive policies that seek to open up new opportunities.

What would justify affirmative action? Presumably, most all affirmative action policies would be unjustifiable if racial inequality arises from (1) innate biological inferiority (overwhelming evidence refutes this notion entirely); (2) cultural pathologies that deemphasize hard work, education, etc (some empirical evidence supports this); or (3) voluntary choices to pursue the paths that they do (very unlikely). However, what affirmative action policies are justified if (a) discrimination and stereotypes play a role in keeping a race down (informal barriers) or (b) structural based obstacles like segregation or a lack of family connections work against a race (formal barriers)?

Even libertarians think that structural or systematic obstacles stemming from government’s duplicitous treatment of different races should be abolished. But, to the extent that discrimination (overt and unconscious) still exists, should quotas, recruiting campaigns, or employee support programs be provided to members of a disadvantaged race? Although express quotas in hiring and school admissions are prohibited by law, unspoken redistributions of opportunity in many careers and school admissions are measurable statistically and legal. So, should discrimination be remedied by redistributions of opportunities? Such an approach would be an equality of outcomes approach. 

Affirming a belief in equality of opportunity implies a belief that government should make sure everyone starts off in the same place, not that everyone ends up in the same condition. However, the issue is complicated by the fact that people aren’t born in the same place. Although we are all of equal value in the eyes of our Heavenly Father, some of us are born to poor parents, others to rich parents; some are born in the United States, others in Somalia; some to parents who love one another, others never know one of their parents; etc. The only way to get everyone started off equally would be to institute some Spartan program of community child-rearing and a total prohibition of any gifts whether given inter vivos or after death. However, that just seems inherently wrong and completely inconsistent with freedom.

Should we simply ignore birth inequalities? I am tempted to say that it is better to let mysterious fate distribute opportunity rather than the arbitrary or fleeting preferences of government. But, I don’t think such an extreme view is the only answer to this puzzle.

A certain degree of economic inequality is desirable. Inequality provides rewards for hard work, talent, and achievement. It provides lubricant for social enterprise and progress. However, when inequality becomes too great, it animates pride, exploitation, discontent, and rebellion that cause societal decline. When crafting solutions to inequality, government should not focus on where to strike a balance between inequality and equality. Rather, I think the focus should be on balancing economic mobility with the freedom to bequest good things to our loved ones. That isn’t very precise; but I don’t think precise is possible. The slightest possibility of reaching the top of the Forbes Richest People list in a single lifetime is all that is necessary for proper income mobility in my view. 

I am thus only in favor of redistributive policies to the extent that all people have the minimum necessities of education, food, shelter, medical care, and life guidance to change their own fortunes and achieve unlimited success with the probabilities of economic success (for full-time, committed individuals mid-career) being chartable on a bell curve. With a more virtuous society, the bell curve will shift towards the prosperous; with a society in moral decline will shift towards the poor. But, the possibility to succeed or to lose should always be present. Real freedom can only be present if we are responsible for the consequences of our choices.

Given my acceptance of some forms of redistributive policies, it is worth mentioning that such policies have been egregiously mismanaged. First, the government not only redistributes things that are not the minimum necessities I described, but are actually detrimental to a disadvantaged person's chances of improving his or her situation. People don’t need a T.V. In fact, TVs do more damage than good. Somehow, people on government stipends for poverty, unemployment, etc afford televisions. People don’t need more bedrooms than there are people in their family; yet I see that in my service to those in government subsidized (or furnished) housing.  And, even the things government provides that people do need as minimum necessities are mismanaged on a large scale. Student loans are given in excessive amounts and without any risk assessment. Medicare pays for unnecessary stuff and pays more for the same services when compared to Veteran Affairs. Redundant programs (there are 23 agencies that provide independent and overlapping assistance to former USSR countries, 12 agencies that ensure food safety requirements are met, and the list goes on for a very long time) are the norm. The mismanagement of what should be proper government redistribution and regulation purposes cannot be understated.

I should also say that income mobility is not the most important thing in the world. Even people who end up not able to break through their birth social class can live joyful and meaningful lives. Indeed, the rich are often less happy, probably because they focus too much on money and too little on the more important things of life like faith, family, friends, and developing an honorable and virtuous character. Equality and freedom are instrumental in bringing forth a virtuous society. But, neither is the end in itself. Government policies should reflect that emphasis on virtuous living through freedom and equality rather than freedom and equality at the expense of virtue.





The Future Role of Finance in the United States

Monday, September 3, 2012

                                                                                          Photo: Ramy Majouji

In this post, I will try to paint in broad strokes my understanding of what caused the 2007 economic downturn and what I think it should mean for the future of the finance sector in the United States.

Starting in the 1990s and continuing into 2006, housing prices increased steadily and substantially. Variable rate mortgages and other sub-prime loans were riskily extended to those with relatively low credit ratings. Buyers assumed they would be able to pay the higher interest rates that kicked in after a designated time period because they thought their careers would progress or, in the alternative, they thought they could just sell their house for a profit. Overconfidence in the stability of the rising housing market prompted speculators to purchase, flip, and develop real property with little hesitation. The housing bubble grew until it burst in late-2006 and 2007. In most of the country, home prices initially only stalled. However, in markets like Florida, Nevada, Arizona, and California where there was an especially pronounced oversupply of housing, the prices dropped abruptly. The other states followed suit.

Then, in 2008, Bear Stearns, a giant investment bank was pulled into the red by its failing hedge funds that were heavily composed of investments in mortgage backed securities. Government sponsored enterprises Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, dealers in mortgage backed securities, were both collapsing. The U.S. government took over management of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and bailed out AIG, a reinsurer of mortgage securities that was on the brink of failure too. By March of 2009, the Dow Jones had dropped from a high of 14,000 in 2006 to a mere 6,547.

Other financial industry giants were also failing. Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy and Merrill Lynch sold out to Bank of America hastily to avoid the same red-lettered fate. With other banking institutions like Citigroup teetering, the Legislature passed a $700 billion (yes, billion; as much as the entire GDP of Indonesia) bailout called TARP. They bought billions of dollars worth of stock in banks like Citigroup and guaranteed billions more dollars in loans. Taxpayers might still be Citigroup's largest shareholder. And yet, they cannot pass the government stress test even today.

The manufacturing industry suffered as a result of the crisis too. So the government poured billions of additional dollars into General Motors and Chrysler in addition to the TARP bailout. But both automobile companies and numerous other manufacturing companies went bankrupt anyway.

These problems affected the entire economy, making for fewer American jobs. In an effort to raise the unemployment rate, Congress provided a $787.2 billion (although the encumbered nature of some of the "investments" probably raise the true price to above $1 trillion) Economic Stimulus Package. Near the same time, Congress guaranteed billions more dollars of loans to failed banks.

The economic downturn has engendered a lot of anger (often directed at the finance industry and politicians) and even more finger pointing. Most likely, the combination of low mortgage interest rates and deregulation was the primary cause, although financial globalization, global imbalance of debt surplus and deficit, executive compensation, and credit cards among other factors likely contributed to the problem. The blame game is futile. What is important is learning from the past and moving forward instead of backwards (although perhaps something we did in the past is better).

We should not be mad at finance as a whole. The finance sector and many of its innovative financial instruments have enabled socially beneficial enterprises that were unimaginable before stock markets, mortgages, loans, bonds, swaps, options, micro-loans, crowd funding, etc. Therefore, the solution to the economic downturn caused by the housing crash is not to hastily restrict the size and inventiveness of the finance and business industries. Rather, regulations should be thought-out and designed to channel financial creativity in ways that most benefits the ability of small businesses and huge corporations to capitalize, grow, innovate, and succeed on the world stage.

One challenge faced by legislatures and economic policymakers is the fact that innovations in finance often help society; but, innovations in finance make finance more complex and harder to predict and understand thus making them more risky. Perhaps the price for the benefits of big and complex finance instruments is occasional bubbles and economic downturns. But, perhaps the cost is worth it. On the other hand, repentance is often harder than not messing up in the first place. Perhaps getting out of the economic ditches does take longer than not getting in them in the first place. I don't know the answer. But, I bet it is somewhere in the middle. Nations that are slow to innovate in finance and who make it hard to buy and sell risk lag behind other nations in political stability and economic growth (e.g. compare Ghana and S. Korea who had similar political and economic situations in 1960. Other factors played a role too [fertility rates, Ghana taking IMF loans, South Korea's linguistic and cultural unity, etc], but it is far-fetched to deny that S. Korea's financial acumen played no role).

The replacement of faith with moral relativity and cynicism also contributes to economic downturns. Without unifying belief in post-death consequences, there is no forceful constraint on behavior when there is pressure to act selfishly. My careful observations confirm that faithful people have more of a stomach to do what is right when nobody is looking. As the priority of religion dwindles in America, I predict that business and finance leaders will be less and less bound by morals and they will have more need of being restricted by economic regulations and criminal laws that will, in turn, burden the full potential of businesses and the finance sector to do good for society. Although a strong moral education and ethical character among leaders will not solve all the complex social risks of finance innovation, it is certainly an important part of the solution.

In short, I would say that the proper course for the United States vis-a-vis the finance industry is two-fold. First, complexity and innovation in finance should be encouraged, but not to such a degree that regulators, shareholders, and legislators can't understand reflect on the implications of the develpments. Regulation should be efficient and not overlapping or over-broad. Second (and the government's role is limited here), religion and traditional values need to have a stronger presence in the lives of Americans. This starts in the home.